| Click for the Finfacts Ireland Portal Homepage |

Finfacts Business News Centre

 Irish Economy
 EU Economy
 US Economy
 UK Economy
 Global Economy
 Asia Economy


How to use our RSS feed

Follow Finfacts on Twitter

Web Finfacts

See Search Box lower down this column for searches of Finfacts news pages. Where there may be the odd special character missing from an older page, it's a problem that developed when Interactive Tools upgraded to a new content management system.


Finfacts is Ireland's leading business information site and you are in its business news section.


Finfacts Homepage

Irish Share Prices

Euribor Daily Rates

Irish Economy

Global Income Per Capita

Global Cost of Living

Irish Tax - Income/Corporate

Global News

Bloomberg News

CNN Money

Cnet Tech News


Irish Independent

Irish Times

Irish Examiner

New York Times

Financial Times

Technology News




Content Management by interactivetools.com.

News : US Economy Last Updated: Apr 2, 2014 - 12:02 PM

Corporate Tax: Caterpillar case shows lucrative market for US tax dodges sold by PwC
By Michael Hennigan, Finfacts founder and editor
Apr 2, 2014 - 10:22 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Corporate Tax: Hearings by the US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations Tuesday, on the Caterpillar scheme that was devised by PwC (PricewaterhouseCoopers), showed how easy US corporate taxes can be dodged and the huge money-making incentive the Big 4 accounting firm has in maintaining the status quo.

Julie Lagacy, vice president of Caterpillar's finance services division, told the subcommittee, "Caterpillar complies with US tax laws and we pay everything we owe."

Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky, said “We’ve got the wrong people on trial here. The tax code should be on trial.”

He added that Caterpillar, the giant construction and mining equipment manufacturer, deserved an apology for the “inquisition” and should be given a reward for keeping jobs in the US instead of moving them overseas.

Up to 1999, Caterpillar's US operations bought CAT-branded parts from mostly US suppliers and sold them to dealers overseas. Those sales incurred US corporate income taxes and PwC earned $55m for proposing in September 1998 to Caterpillar that a Swiss unit should buy the parts and then sell them on to dealers, leaving Caterpillar's US operations out of the transaction and greatly reducing the US tax bill.

The subcommittee found that Caterpillar has been saving as much as $300m a year in US taxes.

Reuven S. Avi-Yonah, a professor of law and director of the International Tax Master of Law Program at the University of Michigan Law School, on Tuesday in testimony [pdf] described to the panel how the dodge worked. 

Prof Avi-Yonah said in respect of the logistics, "physically nothing was changed. The parts were still shipped by the suppliers to Morton (Illinois) and shipped by Caterpillar from Morton to the independent dealers, without any involvement by CSARL (the Swiss tax avoidance unit). Caterpillar still ran the logistics business as it did before, except that it did so as an agent for CSARL, the owner of the parts destined for foreign markets."

Prof Avi-Yonah also noted that shifting profits to Switzerland, must have economic "substance," or a valid business rationale, as opposed to merely reducing tax liability. He said the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) could argue that Caterpillar didn't meet that test because most of the value in the parts business was created in the U.S., not Switzerland.

On the level of royalties paid, Prof Avi-Yonah said the IRS could argue that the royalties paid by the Swiss subsidiary are too low, but noted that "the IRS has not generally been successful in transfer-pricing litigation and…the Caterpillar business restructuring follows a common model" used by many other global companies.

In a 2008 email, Thomas F. Quinn, a PwC tax partner, warned the company that it could lose tax benefits if some Swiss-based product managers relocated to the US. The managers' presence in Switzerland was part of Caterpillar's justification for recording the bulk of the profits from the overseas sales of replacement parts there rather than in the US, cutting tax liabilities.

"We are going to have to create a story that will put some distance between them [the managers] and the parts…to retain the benefit," Quinn wrote to Steven R. Williams, a managing director at PwC. "Get ready to do some dancing."

Williams replied: "What the heck. We'll all be retired when this comes up on audit."

Asked by Senator Carl Levin, the panel chairman, to explain the emails, PwC's Quinn said, "Senator, that was a very poor choice of words."

Robin Beran, Caterpillar’s chief tax officer, agreed with the panel that there are no warehouses or manufacturing facilities in Switzerland for the parts business, but noted that Caterpillar is carefully examined by US tax officials, who sit outside his office. They have cleared the company’s taxes through 2006 and are working on later years.

Senate panel hearings written testimony

Related Articles
Related Articles

© Copyright 2011 by Finfacts.com

Top of Page

US Economy
Latest Headlines
US jobs rose by 215,000 in July; Unemployment rate stable at 5.3%
US economy grew at weak pace in Q2 2015 - Worst expansion since 1945
Decoupling of per capita GDP, productivity, private employment, and median family income in America
US economy stumbles again in 2015
Income gap highest in 30 years; No inequality rise in best-paying US firms
Fed minutes raise doubts about fragility of US recovery
Senate Democrats block trade deal authority for Obama
Five firms held 25% of top US non-financial companies cash pile in 2014
US added 223,000 jobs in April; Broad jobless rate at 10.8%
Investment struggles as dividends/ share buybacks at top US firms to exceed $1tn in 2015
US economic growth plunged in Q1 2015
Why the Fed may (almost) never raise interest rates
US jobless rate falls to 5.5%; Broad rate at 11%; Participation rate at 1978 level
US added 257,000 jobs in January; Broad jobless rate at 11.3%
US economy will soon see best years in a decade
US annualised GDP slowed sharply in final quarter 2014
US budget deficit to fall to 2.6% of GDP in 2015
US added 252,000 jobs in December; Jobless rate falls to 5.6%
US adds 321,000 jobs in November; Private sector adds 10.9m jobs in 57 months of growth
US manufacturing slowed in November
US retail spending over Thanksgiving weekend fell 11%
US consumer spending weak in October; Business investment fell again
US third-quarter GDP revised up to 3.9% annualised rate
After destroying banking secrecy US helps Swiss exporters
US oil imports from OPEC cartel at 30-year low
Tax-inverted "Irish" firm Actavis agrees to buy US Botox maker Allergan
US nonfarm payroll employment rose 214,000 in October' Jobless @ 6-year low
Swiss bankers await fallout of US tax evasion acquittal
Two PMI reports give contrasting trends on US manufacturing
US GDP increased at annualised 3.5% in third quarter of 2014
US city home price growth slowed again in August; Consumer confidence rebounded in September
US new orders for manufactured durable goods fell again in September
Loans to buy US shares at record highs
Global markets slide; US industrial production best in 3 years & jobless claims in 14-year low
US federal budget deficit dips to 2.9% of GDP in fiscal year 2014
US added 248,000 jobs in September; Jobless rate falls to 5.9%
US set to become world’s leading liquid petroleum producer again
Obama issues new rules to combat tax inversions
US Securities and Exchange Commission to pay $30m award to foreign whistleblower
Typical American household income in 2013 was below the 1989 level