Connemara, West of Ireland. Image: ireland.com |
Irish Budget 2014: A former senior IMF official has warned that austerity could be ‘self-defeating’
for Ireland and the Government should consider putting the remaining planned
three years of public spending cutbacks and tax rises on ice. He also suggested
that innovative alternatives should be explored - - it could be a good thing but
confronting bitter home truths was last done more than a half century ago. Given
the external lifelines, the
current situation is likely not yet dire enough
to trigger a new Whitaker moment.
Ashoka Mody, former International Monetary Fund Ireland mission chief,
now a visiting professor of International Economic Policy at the Woodrow Wilson
School of Public and International Affairs at Princeton University, threw the
cat among the pigeons in the normal pre-budget mating ritual that will continue
until the budget is announced on Tuesday, October 15, 2013.
Speaking yesterday on RTÉ's This Week programme, Prof Mody was asked if Ireland should
reduce the deficit in 2014 to 5.1% of GDP (gross domestic product) or by the cash amount of €3.1bn.
He said: "If a €3.1bn reduction is planned, then that number should be
considerably lowered. I would even ask the question why can we not consider the
possibility for the next three years, as an experiment, there be no further
“We have to ask ourselves why Ireland is not growing . . . It’s hard for me to
believe that austerity is not contributing to this,” he added and noted that the
“orthodoxy that the only way to establish market credibility” was to pursue
austerity policies but five years of crisis and two recent years of no growth
needed “deep thinking” on whether this was the right course of action.
“At this point it looks like, given the debt dynamics, if debt levels remain
where they are and growth remains where it is, there is never going to be a
reduction in the debt ratio the foreseeable future and so logically we are left
with the only other option: Generating growth by abandoning the sever commitment
to austerity and hoping there will be a short-term boost to growth, which not
only improves growth, but brings down debt levels".
Asked about how important it was for Ireland to have legacy debt dealt with
through the European Stability Mechanism, Prof Mody said: "The likelihood that
legacy debt will be financed by the ESM is almost zero. At this time the
politics of financing legacy debt is such that I would be astonished if that
Pension fund stimulus
Michael Noonan, finance minister, will soon have the €6.4bn residue of the
public pension fund available in cash and he is reported to have asked
public service departmental heads for ideas on job projects.
In the run-up to the general election in 2016, there will be lots of windy
announcements on projects including wind ones, that will give an impression of
action but do not confuse that with a jobs strategy.
Of course cutting public spending and raising taxes has an impact on jobs but
arguments about the wisdom of austerity should distinguish between economies
such as that of the United States and small countries such as Ireland as members
of a currency union, that are dependent on foreign lenders for most of their
By the end of this year, the total debt from accumulated deficits to cover
day-to-day Irish public spending (excluding bank support and interest on the
public debt) in the period 2008-2013, will amount to €60bn - - equivalent to
almost half the value of annual gross national product (GNP).
Austerity has impacted a minority of the population and in 2012, €5.0bn was
spent on foreign travel and €3.2bn on travel in Ireland.
We said last week that the State is supporting a half million people excluding
dependents, through unemployment benefit payments and various back-to-work
Claims of adding 2,000 jobs a month in the private sector are bogus but the
Government may well meet its target of increasing employment by 100,000 in the
period 2012-2016 but most of the jobs will not be sustainable ones.
Prof Mody's call for “deep thinking” is laudable but it's not going to
happen.Microsoft is delusionally declared Ireland's biggest exporter after a
37% jump in its Irish booked revenues in its fiscal 2012; Dell gets a fourth
spot in a fantasy league because it books the output of its Polish plant in
Ministers claim tax-related accounting transactions at multinational firms that
give an illusion of a services exports boom, is real but there is in reality as
much substance to the additional economic activity as there is in a leprechaun's
The flagship enterprise policy to be recognised as a 'world-class knowledge
economy' by 2013 is a failure but that is not recognised by policy makers,
the dependent vested interests and out-of-their depth Oireachtas members.
Finfacts is the only media outlet, which has reported that patent
applications at the Irish Patents Office in 2012 fell to the lowest level
since the early 1980s - The Irish Times has a science editor.
“Ireland had a genuine growth miracle, but it had run its course by 2000. For the next decade there was a bubble which was seen as a continuation of the miracle,” Prof Mody said in his interview and questioned where Ireland’s growth would come from in the future.
However, the biggest challenge over the short term was to deliver any sort of growth.
The Government had taken “ownership and internalised” the austerity model that it was forced to accept as part of the bailout.
A key factor in developing a credible jobs strategy is to understand why direct
jobs in the internationally tradeable goods and services sectors, were static in
the period 2001-2007 despite an unprecedented boom.
The first step in developing a sustainable strategy is to junk
to spin at ministerial level and enable an honest assessment of the challenges.
Irish Budget 2014 Page
Check out our
subscription service, Finfacts Premium
, at a low annual charge of €25.
Economy: Action Plan for Jobs 2016 target dependent on fake jobs
Anglo Irish Bank: Outrage from top debtor of western
Irish Patents Office applications in 2012 fell to
Microsoft tops Irish exporters' fantasy league; 37% rise in 2012
praises and damns Ireland's state of fiscal transparency
Economy: ESRI scenario of stagnation likelier than recovery
Economy 2013: Number of early-stage entrepreneurs in Ireland is low and falling
Elan: Most valuable Irish firm becomes cash/ royalty
Economy 2013: Only growth in Ireland is in freelance 'jobs'
spends 50% above the EU average per capita on drugs
Ireland's Actual Individual Consumption per capita below EU average in 2012
Economy 2013: New jobs data missing inconvenient facts
Economy 2013: Jobs in export sectors 20,000 below year 2000 level
Apple, taxes, Irish economy and creating 200,000 net jobs
Irish Economy: No growth in 2012; 6,500 direct jobs
account for 52% of services exports
Irish Economy: Innovation, a
failed enterprise policy and inconvenient facts for 2013