The Irish Independent reports that the ultimate cost
of the European Union's planned €35bn financial transaction tax will be borne by
ordinary citizens and taxpayers and its effects will harm small and medium-sized
businesses, the International Banking Federation (IBFed) has warned Finance
Minister Michael Noonan.
The IBFed has written to Mr Noonan in his capacity as president of the EU's
Ecofin council, spelling out what it believes are the dangers of the
controversial financial transactions tax (FTT) that is due to come into force
Although Ireland is not one of the 11 EU member states that is introducing
the divisive FTT, it is responsible, as the holder of the EU presidency, for its
Plans for an EU-wide FTT were ditched last year when it became clear that
some countries had deep reservations about the proposals. There were concerns
that the tax could result in financial firms leaving the International Financial
Services Centre in Dublin or reducing their activities there.
But the EU is enabling member states that do want to introduce the tax to do
so under the so-called "enhanced co-operation" procedure.
That allows a proposal to be adopted by a minimum of nine member states, even
if other members don't plan to do so. The countries that have signed up to the
FTT plan are Germany, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Slovenia, Estonia,
Belgium, Greece, Austria and Slovakia.
Commission reckons that the tax will raise between €30bn and €35bn a year from
the 11 countries that do plan to implement it from next February. Eligible
financial transactions – such as the purchase of sale of assets including
shares, securities, bonds and derivatives – will be subject to the tax where at
party in the transaction is based in a member state that's participating
in the FTT. Research
"Numerous governments, independent research studies, financial market
experts, tax experts, and prominent market commentators have all expressed their
concerns over an FTT and identified its many shortcomings," the head of the
IBFed, Sally Scutt, has told Mr Noonan.
"The IBFed is worried that the EC and some EU member states fail to
understand that the reluctance of a majority of EU member states to participate
in the FTT proposal is due to their negative assessment of its merits," she
The IBFed said that continuing to pursue the FTT in such circumstances
has resulted in a design that "makes a bad tax even worse".
Last week, the UK government launched a legal challenge to the FTT.
The Irish Independent also reports that Taoiseach Enda Kenny and
Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy have both said the European Union faces a
"test of credibility" in ensuring it follows through on its promise to break the
link between sovereign and bank debt.
Both leaders said agreement on banking union – a key step in using European
funds to directly capitalise banks – is crucial, and it is due to be discussed
at an EU summit in June.
It would be the first step towards taking a stake in Irish banks, if the
Government manages to secure such a deal. And using the European Stability
Mechanism (ESM) for capitalising banks may also be required if Spain needs to
further stabilise its beleaguered financial sector.
Mr Kenny and Mr Rajoy met at the Alhambra Palace complex in Granada, Spain,
yesterday as part of Ireland's EU presidency.
The Taoiseach said he was also there to "show solidarity" with Mr Rajoy and
the Spanish people as they face their own economic difficulties. Mr Kenny will
also meet Portuguese leader Pedro Passos Coelho today.
Mr Kenny said the decision of EU leaders at the European Council last June to
break the link between sovereign and bank debt still stands.
Tanaiste Eamon Gilmore described it as a "game changer" at the time, but some
leaders, such as German Chancellor Angela Merkel, have since poured cold water
on the idea of refunding Irish taxpayers for money they have already poured into
Mr Kenny said that banking union is of "immense importance to the future of
the union itself".
Mr Rajoy added that getting agreement on banking union is a "test of
credibility for the EU".
The Irish Times reports that the role of small- and medium-sized enterprises in Europe will be discussed at a
meeting of MPs and MEPs in Dublin this morning.
The parliamentarians are meeting in Dublin Castle to consider strategies to
harness the potential of SMEs and foster an entrepreneurial Europe.
Damien English, chair of the select subcommittee on jobs, enterprise and
innovation, said SMEs have a vital role to play in contributing to economic
growth and employment in Ireland and the European Union.
“If the EU and Ireland are to deliver on the Europe 2020 priorities of smart,
sustainable and inclusive growth, competitiveness needs to be centre stage.”
Speakers at the conference include Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation
Richard Bruton, EU Commissioner for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion
Lszl Andor, Joanna Drake, DG Enterprise and Industry at the European Commission,
and BeActive Media director Triona Campbell.
The Irish Times also reports that pharmacists have called for the lifting of a provision of the Pharmacy Act 2007
that prevents individuals who are bankrupt from being registered as pharmacists.
The call was made at the national pharmacy conference held by the Irish Pharmacy
Union in Maynooth, Co Kildare, at the weekend.
Under the Act, the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland may not register an
individual as a pharmacist if the person is an undischarged bankrupt. The
restriction is not imposed on other healthcare professionals and is not
referenced in bankruptcy legislation.
Dublin pharmacist Roy Hogan, chairman of the IPU’s business strategy group, said
the rule served as a double punishment for pharmacists with financial problems.
The Irish Examiner reports that new restrictions on
lending have had a severe impact on the size of the credit union loan book, but
membership of the movement continues to grow. There are 3.1m members across 32
counties making the Irish movement one of the most popular in Europe.
The ILCU held its annual general meeting in the University of Limerick over the
weekend which saw over 2,000 delegates from nearly 500 credit unions attend
focus groups and discussions on the challenges facing the movement.
Delegates are keenly aware that the credit union movement is facing serious
restructuring as a result of the economic crisis.
Recent regulatory and legislative changes, as well as restructuring within the
sector, were key agenda items, as credit unions move to offer a broader range of
services to satisfy the increasing needs of their growing membership.
President of the ILCU Jimmy Johnstone said that the credit union wanted to be
seen as more than just a provider of loans. “We are a volunteer-led,
cooperative, not-for-profit movement and we have much to contribute.
“Our bottom line is not about empire building or status symbols. Sure we provide
financial services but we want to provide a lot more.”
Mr Johnstone stressed the community and social role credit unions play. He said
this was the core of the movement and something that should not be
underestimated. “Credit unions play an educational, social and, of course,
community role, the significance of which should never be underestimated. Credit
unions are vital components of over 400 culturally and geographically distinct
and diverse rural, urban and industrial communities around Ireland.”
Minister for Finance Michael Noonan said the Government was committed to
ensuring that Credit Unions emerge from the financial crisis.
“While much of the focus has been on legislation and regulatory changes, we
should not lose sight of the destination. There is no doubt that credit unions
are going through a major transformation. The Government remains fully committed
to supporting the credit union movement throughout this process. We want credit
unions to emerge stronger so that you can continue to play an important role in
local and national life in this country.”
Check out our
, at a low annual charge of €25 - - if
you are a regular user of Finfacts, 50 euro cent a week is hardly a huge ask to
support the service.