Irish Economy 2013: Half of all lending to SME (small and medium enterprises)
business is in arrears, according to the Central Bank. Fiona Muldoon, the
director of credit institution supervision at the bank told a conference in
Tralee yesterday that of the €50bn lent to the sector by the domestic banks,
some €25bn was impaired. This is a serious issue for the economy and five years
after the crash, Central Bank action is overdue. It’s extraordinary that this
situation still remains full of unknowns. With so many loans non-performing,
what economic scenario in the next 5 years will change the fundamentals?
said on Thursday that "in effect, in Ireland, literally and figuratively,
all roads lead to property." Given that 70% of people in private sector employment
are employed by SMEs there is a...direct knock-on for these employees (&
past employees) into the whole area of household debt and mortgage arrears in
She added: "When it comes to SME arrears within the banks, there are complex
issues and high levels of inter-connectedness. In many cases family businesses
borrowed to expand the business, invest in their premises and maybe a buy-to-let
property for their pension. Some cases include personal guarantees or drawdowns
on the family home. That same SME is now the only source of cash flow in
servicing both direct and indirect debt. Where that SME is consumer facing,
they are facing restricted demand brought about by unemployment, reduced
consumer confidence and the resultant increased savings levels we have seen over
the last several years. In effect households are de-leveraging alongside the
Benoît Cœuré, member of the executive board of
the ECB, said at a seminar in Dublin Thursday, that the SMEs are more likely
to be affected by excessive bank risk aversion and thus by outright rationing of
credit provision than are large firms. Difficulties in borrowing, which
influence not only their day-to-day activities, but also their ability to grow,
may then easily transform liquidity constraints into solvency risk.
Cœuré, said: "To illustrate this point, two facts
are worth mentioning. First, SMEs tend to face higher costs for bank finance. A
simple comparison between small loans (typically to SMEs) and very large loans
(typically to large corporations) shows that euro area SMEs were paying on
average around 160 basis points (1.6%) more than large euro area companies in the six
months up to January 2013. There is also a substantial divergence across euro
area countries which has worsened since the beginning of the financial crisis
(Chart 3). For instance, in the same period, the spread was around 50 basis
points for SMEs in Austria and Belgium, but 261 in Spain and 174 in Ireland.
Just to put this in a “historical” perspective: between 2003 and 2008 the same
spread was 84 basis points in the euro area, 79 basis points in Spain and 44
basis points in Ireland.
Fiona Muldoon indicated that the Central Bank hasn't
got detailed facts on the situation and has only begun to address the issue in recent times. She doesn’t inspire much confidence with this accountancyspeak:
“We believe that the banks now have credible credit assessment tools. We
have overseen that operational skills and resources are improved and that
appropriate external help is engaged where necessary.
Policies and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are in use in the banks to
measure their success. The banks’ management teams must now be accountable
for the implementation of the strategy and measured in terms of their
success in that implementation. We receive regular updates from the banks
management on their progress against plan. In this way, restructuring and
re-underwriting will continue to take place throughout the year.”
Progress against plan?
The fact that half the loans value is impaired
makes this a crisis issue.
So while the NTMA, the debt agency, is lauding
every sale of bills or bonds as a huge achievement towards returning to market,
the Central Bank is saying that the banks remain in a mess. Apart from
individual mortgage arrears, many SME owners have investments in bust hotels
It’s a clash of fairytale spinners at government
level, while agencies such as the Central Bank and the Irish Fiscal Advisory
Council (IFAC) are reluctant to tell little emperors that they have no clothes -
- the renowned American baseball player Yogi Berra (b. 1925) once quipped "It's
déjà vu all over again" and this seems like a replay of policymaking in Irish
Michael Noonan, finance minister, is also trying to ride two horses at the same time — so
on his second objective, after ending the bailout, is to get debt relief from
Europe, but when should the story on SME debt be
The domestic economy has been in a depression since
2008, SMEs, its main economic engine, are deep in debt and with little prospect
of significant growth, the banks will have to write off a lot of it.
Where will the money for recapitalisation come from?
At least, it would be a first step if the Central
Bank had detailed information on the loan situation that it clearly hasn't at
European Commission Factsheet on Irish SMEs [pdf]
Check out our
, at a low annual charge of €25 - - if
you are a regular user of Finfacts, 50 euro cent a week is hardly a huge ask to
support the service.