| Click for the Finfacts Ireland Portal Homepage |

Finfacts Business News Centre

Home 
 
 News
 Irish
 Irish Economy
 EU Economy
 US Economy
 UK Economy
 Global Economy
 International
 Property
 Innovation
 
 Analysis/Comment
 
 Asia Economy

RSS FEED


How to use our RSS feed

 
Web Finfacts

See Search Box lower down this column for searches of Finfacts news pages. Where there may be the odd special character missing from an older page, it's a problem that developed when Interactive Tools upgraded to a new content management system.

Welcome

Finfacts is Ireland's leading business information site and you are in its business news section.

We provide access to live business television and business related videos from: Bloomberg TV; The Wall Street Journal; CNBC and the Financial Times. Click image:

Links

Finfacts Homepage

Irish Share Prices

Euribor Daily Rates

Irish Economy

Global Income Per Capita

Global Cost of Living

Irish Tax 2008

Climate Change Reports

Global News

Bloomberg News

CNN Money

Cnet Tech News

Newspapers

Irish Independent

Irish Times

Irish Examiner

New York Times

Financial Times

Technology News

 

Feedback

 

Content Management by interactivetools.com.

News : Irish Last Updated: Sep 11, 2009 - 8:31:13 AM


NAMA: Cabinet responds to Irish public pressure on "bad bank"; Greens claim credit for following public
By Michael Hennigan, Founder and Editor of Finfacts
Sep 10, 2009 - 6:33:04 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Monopoly gains from land rezoning which has made land scarce in a country that is 4% urbanised, has been Ireland's biggest stealth tax and bonanza for vested interests for decades. Click here for detail on Irish property values and control of land - - NASA says Ireland seems beyond the reach of winter’s icy grip in this true-color Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) Earth Observatory image from January 4, 2003. The rugged cliffs that mark the island’s west coast are showing their red-brown rocky surface, but the low-lying interior region is still wearing the island’s signature green.

NAMA: The Cabinet responded to Irish public pressure and academic economists on Wednesday, by amending the plan for the State "bad bank," which will handle up to €90bn worth of mainly toxic property loans, which will be transferred from Irish banks. Green Party ministers have been quick to claim credit for following the public but before heading off on holidays in July, they approved draft legislation that Wednesday's changes show to have been fundamentally flawed.

During August, as ministers and the rest of the Oireachtas were on holidays, academic economists, including the incoming governor of the Central Bank, Prof. Patrick Honohan, led the public debate on the lopsided provisions in the draft legislation and the concept of valuation on the basis of "long-term economic value," which would allow wide latitude, depending on what the assumptions were - -  in particular ones made by vested interests.

The working of Irish politics, which usually only responds with other than glacial speed when a crisis becomes dire, brings to mind quotes from Frenchman Alexandre Ledru-Rollin (1807-1874): “There go the people. I must follow them, for I am their leader,” and American Groucho Marx (1890-1977): “Those are my principles, and if you don't like them... well, I have others.”

The Cabinet agreed the NAMA Bill on Wednesday and it has been published today:

 National Asset Management Agency Bill 2009

UCD economics professor Karl Whelan's  presentation to Labour’s Parliamentary Party meeting on NAMA on Wednesday, Sept 09, 2009.

The framework on risk-sharing between the banks and taxpayers will be outlined by the Minister for Finance Brian Lenihan next Wednesday when the Dáil debate on the Bill begins.

Green Party Minister for Energy and Communications Eamon Ryan said that the risk-sharing mechanism between NAMA and the banks would involve the Government issuing subordinated bonds as well as those backed by the European Central Bank. The exact proportions will not be disclosed until next week.

Under the Government’s original plan, agreed by Ryan, Green Party leader John Gormley, and colleagues, NAMA would have paid the agreed price in full to the banks at the outset. This meant all the risk would have been on the taxpayer, if NAMA overvalued the loans and losses occurred.

The Cabinet also agreed a number of other key changes:

  • Making it a criminal offence to lobby NAMA.

  • Introducing a windfall tax of 80% on profits gained from increases in land value due to rezoning decisions to ensure that speculation is not rewarded in the future.

  • Giving NAMA the power to make land banks available in a "controlled manner" in future to avoid a repeat of the property bubble.

  • Obliging NAMA to report to Finance Minister Brian Lenihan every three months instead of the original proposal of once a year.

  • A condition of participating in NAMA will be a guarantee by the banks that a fixed percentage of the loans issued will be lent on to small and medium enterprises.

  • Directors of institutions participating in NAMA appointed before 2008, will now be required to step down over the next two years.

  • The criteria in assessing the long-term value of loans will include the Minister for the Environment’s analysis of the extent of zoning and planning permissions granted, the Minister for Transport’s analysis of future land use based on transport planning, and the Minister for Energy’s analysis of trends in energy prices.

  • The amount NAMA can borrow without the approval of the Minister for Finance has been reduced from a €10 billion limit in the draft Bill to €5 billion.

The Irish Examiner says that nine senior members of the State agency, NTMA -  - the National Treasury Management Agency - -  which will oversee NAMA, were paid more than €200,000 last year.

It’s understood the nine high-earners include accountant Brendan McDonagh, who has been appointed interim managing director of NAMA.

The Fine Gael Deputy Leader & Finance Spokesman Richard Bruton has called on the Government to publish the names of the 1,500 people that will be the beneficiaries of the NAMA plan so that the taxpayer can see who they are bailing out.

Speaking after the Cabinet signed off on the NAMA legislation, Deputy Bruton said: "At its core, NAMA is a secretive, tax-funded, politically directed work-out process for 1,500 of the most powerful, well connected, business people in Ireland’.

“Not only will Irish taxpayers get scalped by bank speculators if NAMA is allowed to deliberately over-pay them for their toxic developer loans, we’ll then be in danger of getting scalped a second time by the developers themselves.

“Secrecy in the use of taxpayers’ money is at the very heart of NAMA. Under the current draft NAMA Bill, the public can be prevented from knowing:

  • The names of developers whose loans are being bought by NAMA with taxpayers’ money;

  • The price taxpayers are paying for these loans;

  • The original value of those loans and of the lands purchased, and the amount of money that the developer themselves put into the deals;

  • The actions being taken by NAMA to recover the loans now owned by the taxpayer;

  • The names of the people that will benefit from the €10 billion in new tax-funded loans that NAMA can give out to developers to finish projects.

“This raises the alarming possibility that NAMA will use taxpayers’ money to buy a €200 million non-performing developer loan from a bank, and lend a further €100 million to the same developer to complete the development, without the public ever knowing what has been done with their money.

“Not only will the absence of disclosure and transparency provisions leave the taxpayer ignorant and vulnerable about what is going on, but the draft legislation also gives extra-ordinary powers for political interference at every stage in the process, from hiring and firing, asset valuation and the rules of engagement with defunct developers.

“This is a frightening formula for sweetheart deals, crony capitalism and taxpayer losses on a mass scale over the next decade, at the very time when we need to restore our international reputation and use every euro to protect public services and the fairness and competitiveness of our tax system.

“The Government likes to cite Sweden as an example of where a NAMA-type bank rescue worked. But surely if there is one thing that we have learned about our political system and civic institutions over the last decade, it is that Ireland is not Sweden.

“In countries with political institutions more vulnerable to business lobbying, this approach does not have a proven track record.

“Only last November, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the world’s repository of expertise in financial crises, finished a study on banking and property busts in seven other countries where the NAMA approach was adopted, and concluded that “Government-owned asset management companies appear largely ineffective in resolving distressed assets, largely due to political and legal constraints” and that “the use of Asset Management Companies is positively correlated with peak non-performing loans and fiscal costs”.

“In layman’s terms, the IMF believes that NAMA type bank rescues can end up costing tax-payers an arm and a leg because politically-directed state quangos are much less skilled than private bankers at recovering loans from rich, powerful and well-connected borrowers.

“The stand-out example is France, where a “NAMA type” asset management company in the 1990s lost a total of €18 billion out of €28 billion of assets purchased by the taxpayer from Credit Lyonnais."
 

Related Articles


© Copyright 2009 by Finfacts.com

Top of Page

Irish
Latest Headlines
National Irish Bank's losses and deposits rose in 2011
Irish Finance Bill 2012: Includes tax incentives for executives of foreign firms and mortgage relief for first time homebuyers
Elan reports pre-tax profits of $560.5m in 2011
Irish low-income families and the unemployed do not have enough money to achieve a basic standard of living
Mexican cement giant Cemex increases offer for remaining stake of Readymix Ireland
Irish pension funds increased 3.7% in January following a 2.4% drop in 2011
Vhi health insurance premiums to rise  by 6% - 12.5%
Irish Health Contribution Refunds
Sky announces 800 new customer care jobs in Dublin over next two years
Ryanair announces fiscal third quarter profit of €15m; Raises full-year forecast
High Court cuts Quinn administrators' €2.75m fee by 20%; Irish public sector institutions again shown to be the 'soft touch'
South African financial firm Investec buys Ireland's NCB Stockbrokers
Government announces measures to reform Ireland’s “arcane” bankruptcy laws; Focus on insolvency, mortgage debt and negative equity
ESRI says Ireland in top rich country ranks for per capita spending on pharmaceuticals; State's drugs bill in 2010 was €1.9bn
Irish pension funds index fell 2.45% in 2011
CRH announces investments of €0.4bn during second-half of 2011
Some 5,700 Irish companies collapsed in period 2008-2011; In 2011 unsecured creditors had €1.2bn in unpaid debt
Central Bank imposes record €3.35m fine on Combined Insurance Company of Europe; Also orders refund of €2.15m to customers
Irish pension funds down slightly in November
Survey of Irish SME firms shows 70% of firms that applied for loans got credit approval
Real cost of Irish public sector staff pensions in 2009 was €10.5bn
Irish Public Service Reform: No bonfire of quangos' "organisational zoo"; Slow-motion process is expected
European Investment Bank is lend total of €325m to ESB and UCD
US firm Prometric to create 100 jobs in Dundalk
Bank of Ireland says trading conditions remain tough
Getting Irish Business Online launches new e-commerce tool
Irish pension managed funds recovered some losses in October
Kerry reports rise in revenues in first nine months of 2011
Hedge fund administrator HedgeServ to add 300 jobs in Dublin
Bruton announces 79 jobs to be created at VistaMed - - a Leitrim medical devices manufacturer
Irish companies have reduced balance sheet pension liabilities by more than €2bn
Bord Gáis Energy Index fell 3% in September; Up 21% in 12 months
Bill Clinton to attend second 'Global Irish Economic Forum'
Irish pension fund returns down 10% in 2011; Annual inflation-adjusted returns over 10 years in the red
High Court authorises Quinn Insurance to draw €738m from State insurance compensation fund
Prospects of saving 600 Dublin jobs at online gambling operation recede
Fifty-three Irish public bodies binned survey on €15bn procurement bill; Interest on national debt at 21% of tax revenues in 2015
Chartered Accountants Ireland refers findings on Ernst & Young's audits of Anglo Irish Bank to disciplinary panel
High Court asks European Court of Justice to rule on dispute between Anglo Irish Bank and Seán Quinn/ family
Noonan publishes Bill to levy 2% on non-life insurance policies to fund bailouts required by Quinn Insurance Ltd