| Click for the Finfacts Ireland Portal Homepage |

Finfacts Business News Centre

Home 
 
 News
 Irish
 Irish Economy
 EU Economy
 US Economy
 UK Economy
 Global Economy
 International
 Property
 Innovation
 
 Analysis/Comment
 
 Asia Economy

RSS FEED


How to use our RSS feed

 
Web Finfacts

See Search Box lower down this column for searches of Finfacts news pages. Where there may be the odd special character missing from an older page, it's a problem that developed when Interactive Tools upgraded to a new content management system.

Welcome

Finfacts is Ireland's leading business information site and you are in its business news section.

Links

Finfacts Homepage

Irish Share Prices

Euribor Daily Rates

Irish Economy

Global Income Per Capita

Global Cost of Living

Irish Tax - Income/Corporate

Global News

Bloomberg News

CNN Money

Cnet Tech News

Newspapers

Irish Independent

Irish Times

Irish Examiner

New York Times

Financial Times

Technology News

 

Feedback

 

Content Management by interactivetools.com.

Analysis/Comment Last Updated: Aug 23, 2010 - 8:24:15 PM


Restrictive budget would kill off Irish economy - - Pat McArdle, Ulster Bank
By Pat McArdle, Chief Economist, Ulster Bank
Mar 30, 2009 - 10:36:25 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Pat McArdle
Irish Economy: With the budget now little more than a week away, the fiscal situation is becoming clearer.

The economic assumption on which it is based will determine whether it is realistic or not. The Taoiseach recently forecast that the economy might contract by 6.5% this year. This is weaker than the 5% consensus forecast, but more optimistic than our own 8% estimate.

As we have said before, even our figure looks optimistic.

Last week’s national accounts data were much weaker than expected and revealed a rate of contraction in the final quarter of around 7%.

The negative carry forward into 2009 is, thus, even greater than expected and the January retail sales were exceptionally weak. The third item in this unholy trio will be the budget, which will add to the downturn. A double-digit contraction in economic activity could now be on the cards, though it is likely that budget will be based on a more conservative number.

In many ways, this is Garret FitzGerald’s budget. He recently campaigned for tax increases to replace the “lost” property taxes. His statistical analysis was correct and there was a need for some action. However, the focus on raising taxes rather than cutting spending was unfortunate and, indeed, reminiscent of the 1980s.

Happily, the extreme weakness of the economy has brought greater balance back into the debate and the Government increasingly acknowledge that an undue reliance on taxes could do permanent damage.

However, the corollary is that the arithmetic is well-nigh impossible. Last week, the Minister for Finance reaffirmed that taxes would undershoot by €3 billion and spending overshoot by €1.5bn. We thus know that he has a €4.5bn gap to plug to keep this year’s deficit to the €18bn, or 9.5% of GDP, notified to Brussels in January.

Remember, however, that he will only have eight months left in which to do so, i.e. the annual requirement is a much bigger €6.75bn. On top of that, we must add the reduction in taxes or negative buoyancy that goes with a restrictive budget, another €2bn, which brings the amount of medicine required to €8.75bn, about 5% of GDP. A restrictive budget of this magnitude would finish an economy which is already on its knees.

The Government should limit the package to €4.5bn with a first year, 2009, impact of €3bn and an associated knock-on tax loss of a billion. This would improve the 2009 deficit by a net €2bn instead of the €4.5bn sought by the minister. The consequent overshoot of the target is €2.5bn and the 2009 deficit would be 12% instead of the 9.5% notified to Brussels.

Even this would be difficult to achieve. How should the €4.5bn headline cuts be split between taxes and spending? I would go for €2bn in taxes and €2.5bn in spending. As pay is likely to be left alone for the time being, non-pay will have to bear the burden. If the Government does not grasp the social welfare nettle they will struggle to cut current spending. By default, capital will come under scrutiny. In the end, there is likely to be a mixture of both current and capital initiatives but, hopefully, the bulk will fall on the current side where the real problem is.

Property and carbon taxes are likely to be signalled but hopefully will not be rushed. Excises and the minor taxes will be raised but income tax will take the bulk of the hit. The administrative difficulties of changing bands and rates at this stage are considerable, but doubling the levy would yield a billion in a full year, leaving another billion to be found elsewhere.

Remember this is but the first of five tough budgets. It should also have a medium-term aspect which must focus on pay and numbers.

Related Articles


© Copyright 2010 by Finfacts.com

Top of Page

Analysis/Comment
Latest Headlines
Dr Peter Morici: US jobs report expected to show little progress; Economy slowing
Dr Peter Morici: Rating downgrades; S&P got France right, Germany wrong
Dr. Peter Morici: Euro is a cruel hoax on Mediterranean nations
Peter Morici: Lacklustre US jobs report expected
Dr Peter Morici: Investors should be wary of buying US Treasuries
Dr Peter Morici: Occupy Wall Street put nation on notice
Dr. Peter Morici: US deficit talks; On the road to Armageddon
Dr Peter Morici: Obama outplays Republicans, Romney at home and on the road
Should Irish universities be trusted with additional fee income?
Dr. Peter Morici: Penn State’s Stain; Big time sports harm universities
Dr Peter Morici: US trade deficit blocks jobs creation and growth
Dr. Peter Morici: Don’t raise taxes or cut defense to solve US budget woes
Dr Peter Morici: Perry tax plan makes little sense
A comeback for Crony Ireland?: Millionaire lawyers oppose change in conservative country
Dr. Peter Morici: The Fed is out of tricks to jump start US housing and economy
Dr. Peter Morici: Free trade Is failing America
Ireland, FDI, and the difference between Aviva and TalkTalk
Dr. Peter Morici: When will President Obama put Americans’ jobs ahead of his own?
Dr. Peter Morici: Greece must default, dump euro
Dr Peter Morici: What President Obama needs to say and do
Dr Peter Morici: No time to panic - - this is not 2008 again
President Gay Byrne and the 'mad people' in Brussels running Ireland
Dr Peter Morici: Fixing markets and US economy must begin in the Oval Office
Dr Peter Morici: S&P downgrade will little affect interest rates or President Obama’s policies
Ireland Post-Bubble: RTÉ and conflict of interest; When the past is inoperative
Dr Peter Morici: Solutions to Slow US Growth: Develop domestic petroleum and address Chinese mercantilism
Dr. Peter Morici: US budget deficit; Republicans need new taxes, President Obama does not
Dr. Peter Morici: No US default, no shutdown inevitable if debt ceiling talks fail
The unforeseen consequences of voluntary debt reprofiling for Ireland
Dr. Peter Morici: The New Imperialism; EU aid package will destroy Greece and enrich Germany
Should corrupt Greece be ejected from Eurozone if it rejects reform?
Dr. Peter Morici: Greece should quit the euro and remark its debt
Ireland, waste incineration and gombeenism
Dr. Peter Morici: US trade deficit slows recovery, jobs creation
Dr. Peter Morici: Lessons from the Eurozone for the United States
Dr. Peter Morici: Lagarde makes sense for the IMF
Obama's message for Ireland and entrepreneurs of gloom: Is féidir linn
Dr. Peter Morici: Greece should restructure debt and abandon the euro + Video interview; France's Christine Lagarde
Dr. Peter Morici: European should head IMF
Dr. Peter Morici: US home sales, gas prices and stocks