| Click for the Finfacts Ireland Portal Homepage |

Finfacts Business News Centre

News Main Page 
 Asia-Pacific Business Week


How to use our RSS feed

Web Finfacts


Finfacts is Ireland's leading business information site and you are in its business news section.

We provide access to live business television and business related videos from: Bloomberg TV; The Wall Street Journal; CNBC and the Financial Times. Click image:


Finfacts Homepage

Global News

Bloomberg News

CNN Money

Cnet Tech News


Irish Independent

Irish Times

Irish Examiner

New York Times

Financial Times

Technology News





News : European Last Updated: Dec 19th, 2007 - 13:17:15

Germany's top Economist says it's not Angela Merkel but the Oil Sheiks who determine the Speed of Global Warming; Demand only response useless
By Finfacts Team
Oct 10, 2007, 11:00

Email this article
 Printer friendly page
Jeremy Rifkin, President of the Foundation on Economic Trends (left), and Professor Hans-Werner Sinn, listen to German Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel. The Chancellor hosted a debate in March 2006, between Rifkin and Sinn, Germany's leading neo-liberal economist, on "The Future of Work".

Professor Hans-Werner Sinn is President of the IFO Institute for Economic Research (since February 1999), Director of the Center for Economic Studies (CES) at the University of Munich (since January 1991), and Professor and chair of economics and public finance at the University of Munich.  Since 2006 Professor Sinn has been President of the International Institute of Public Finance.

The following is a summary of a lecture by Professor Sinn on the challenges of climate change.

Up to now the climate discussion has focused one-sidedly on the reduction of demand for fossil fuel and has neglected the supply side. In his Thuenen Lecture at the conference of the Verein für Socialpolitik, Ifo president, Hans-Werner Sinn, points out that supply and demand together determine how much fossil fuel is extracted and thus also determine the pace with which carbon is released into the atmosphere, creating the greenhouse effect.

The EU's consumption reducing measures are, in his opinion, in vain if the oil sheiks and the other owners of fossil fuels do not cut back their supply. The effect of measures like those of the EU are then not only small but non-existent. As Sinn explains: "With the rigid conduct of the suppliers, the world market price is pushed so far under the level that otherwise would have been achieved so that those countries that do nothing with regard to climate protection will use that much more fossil fuels than that which is saved be the EU. The Chinese continue to step up their CO2-intensive expansion policies and the Americans drive even more SUVs than they used to."

The improvement in housing insulation, the conversion to biodiesel and the construction of cars with lower fuel consumption will be just as useless as windmills or solar roofs, with which electricity and heat is to be generated in Germany, if the oil sheiks remain stubborn. Also France's nuclear reactors would then also make no significant contribution. All these forms of energy would only come in addition to fossil energy. "It is not Angela Merkel who will determine the pace of global warming but Hugo Chávez, Mahmud Ahmadineschad, Putin's oligarchs, the Arabian oil sheiks and a few other potentates."

A reduction of the resource supply via a restriction on consumption by industrial countries is hardly likely, in Sinn's opinion. The supply of fossil deposits that nature has made available is independent of the price reactions that the consumer countries can influence. Sinn doubts that price-reducing measures can induce the suppliers of fossil resources to defer extraction. The supplier reactions that do occur depend on the temporal course of the demand restrictions that the suppliers expect. Indeed it is true that demand restrictions today that are not continued in the future induce the suppliers to defer extraction. However, demand restrictions expected in the future would give them the incentive to extract more in the present. What in fact happens depends on how much demand restriction is implemented in the present and how much is realised and expected in the future.

If there is to be a slowing of resource extraction, the demand restrictions must be eased over time so that the resource providers have an incentive to defer their extraction to a point in time when higher prices can be achieved. "That, however, is hardly possible in reality", Sinn observes. It is more likely that with increasing global warming the demand for policy measures will become increasingly louder, so that in all probability the measures will not be weakened further on but intensified. Since the resource providers would know this, they would anticipate this development with intensified extraction. This could be one of the reasons that world consumption of fossil fuel and the output of carbon dioxide in recent years, despite the expansion of EU environmental protection measures, has increased even further. Sinn speaks here of the "green paradox" of environmental policies.

Policy measures that are truly effective in reducing global warming are rare and have little in common with that which is currently demanded by governments and is publicly discussed in Germany and the rest of Europe. "Meaningful measures include the introduction of worldwide source taxes on capital gains along with a closing of tax havens so that the resource owners would lose their investment alternatives", Sinn explains. In addition, an emissions trading system with no loopholes that would unite all customer countries into a worldwide monopsony* could force the desired amounts from the resource exporters. It would make particular sense to exploit the technical possibilities of sequestering mineral oil. "Rebuilding the forests should have highest priority, however, because forests are the largest storages of carbon on earth that can be controlled by humans", Sinn emphasises. Currently deforestation is leading to the release of more carbon dioxide than from the whole transportation sector. If reforestation were to replace forest destruction, global warming could be slowed down significantly.

*Monopsony is a state in which demand comes from one source.

© Copyright 2007 by Finfacts.com

Top of Page

Latest Headlines
German ZEW Indicator of Economic Sentiment fell in January to a to 15-Year low indicating plunge in investor confidence
UK Annual Consumer Price Inflation held steady in December at 2.1%
Total cost of employment in Ireland at €38,541in 2007 - 16th of 24 EU countries; New EU member states have lowest labour costs
European Union countries fighting over share-out for cutting greenhouse gas emissions; Environment Commissioner now says some biofuels do more harm than good
UK factory gate/wholesale price annual inflation rose to 5% in December - the highest since 1991
Eurozone industrial production fell 0.5% in November
Manchester United almost doubled profit in 2007; Premier League clubs’ revenues to increase significantly in 2007/08 to over £1.76bn
Trichet says ECB is in position of "total alertness" to act in response to price/wage setting linked to the current high Eurozone headline inflation rate
European Central Bank keeps its its benchmark interest rate on hold at 4.00%; Trichet to warn of inflation risks at press conference
Bank of England keeps benchmark interest rate unchanged at 5.50%
European Central Bank expected to keep benchmark interest rate on hold at 4%; Bank of England base rate cut likely
Eurozone Economic Outlook: GDP growth to slow to annual rate of 2.1% in Q2 2008; If negative shocks were to fade economic slowdown may be only transitory
European Commission analysis looks at the role of India in world agriculture
Eurozone GDP revised up to 0.8% in Q3 2007 - up 2.7% in year to September
German exports and retail sales fell in November 2007
UK Consumer Confidence fell in December; Marks & Spencer reports first same-store sales fall in 2 1/2 years on reduced Christmas spending
Eurozone retail sales volume fell 0.5% in November 2007 - down 1.4% on annual basis but up 0.9% in EU27
UK Retail Sales December 2007: A far from Merry Christmas in the High Street
UK sales of commercial property plunged in Q4 2007 because of credit crunch; Market set for biggest annual losses in more than 25 years
Eurozone Business Climate Indicator and Economic Sentiment Indicator weakened in December 2007