||Last Updated: Dec 19th, 2007 - 13:17:15
Irish Economy: No crash in sight nor credible strategy to maintain export-led growth in long-term; Overseas commercial property to remain investment of choice
By Michael Hennigan, Founder and Editor of Finfacts
Jun 6, 2007, 06:53
Email this article
Printer friendly page
Update: June19, 2007: Greencore's Irish operations become property play at time when food industry is faltering
|Export Performance and Competitiveness of the Irish Economy Central Bank of Ireland Quarterly Bulletin 3 2005 - - - It is foreign-owned firms that are driving Irish exports and most of them don't have or need a marketing function in Ireland. The trend of exports from Irish-owned firms is represented by the line at the bottom of the chart and it is almost flatlining.|
In the past week, India reported the best economic growth performance in 20 years in the year ended March 31st while China sought to dampen stockmarket speculation as its economy continues to surge at double-digit growth rates.
In Ireland, its largest exporter Dell prepared to shed 10% of its 4,500 person workforce as part of a global jobs reduction at the struggling PC manufacturer while Bank of Ireland reported a 28% rise in pre-tax profits to €1.9 billion.
“We have a growing population, full employment, strong job creation, rising household income, a high savings ratio together with strong retail sales and industrial production. This economy is in great shape and the outlook remains positive,” Brian Goggin, Bank of Ireland Chief Executive said at a press briefing on the bank’s results.
This is all uncontested.
The SSIA bonanza matured just last month and a reasonable number of consumers have some spare funds to provide for the rainy day or to just boost retail spending.
Whether or not the current slowdown in the housing sector results in a so-called “soft landing,” as significant economic trends generally have long gestation periods, nobody should shy away from asking about a likely outcome in say a decade, when the construction boom in both housing and infrastructure is effectively over.
Also last week, the principal Irish business representative group IBEC, launched an Asia Business Network, to promote knowledge of markets in the region.
Speaking at the launch of the network IBEC Head of Trade and International Relations Pat Ivory said: "There is massive potential to increase Ireland’s level of trade with Asia. In addition to increasing sales of computer, pharmaceutical, food and drinks products, Ireland should also be targeting growth in new emerging sectors such as medical devices and financial services."
Massive potential may be a correct analysis but there is a pertinent fact that we often ignore when we opt for superlatives and dare I say – end up deluding ourselves.
Last February, IBEC published a report on trade with Asia, which said that €10 billion in annual exports should be targeted.
However, most Irish exports to Asia are made by foreign-owned firms in Ireland and marketing decisions are not generally made in Ireland.
In 2006, foreign firms were responsible for 92% of Irish exports and Irish-owned firms mainly exported to the UK market.
Irish industrialist Eoin O'Driscoll, who is chairman of the Irish Government science and policy advisory agency Forfás, told a conference in 2005, that most of the products we manufacture, are designed elsewhere and the bulk of our exports, are marketed/sold by organisations outside Ireland.
In the Irish Times on Friday, April 6th, economist Paul Tansey wrote that Ireland's Celtic Tiger economy, where growth was led by exports, expired in 2001. The demise of the tiger went unmourned and for a simple reason. After hitting a flat patch in 2001-2002, the economy rebounded. Nobody much cared that domestic demand had elbowed out export demand as the engine of economic expansion. What was important was that growth was back. Never mind the quality, feel the width.
| Goodbody Stockbrokers - - Property-related taxes have been an especially important driver of tax revenues. While stamp duty is most visible in this regard, the biggest revenue gatherer is, in fact, VAT receipts from residential construction, which accounts for c.8% of total revenue. Goodbody estimates that property-related taxes have accounted for up to a third of the increase in the total tax take over the past two years. Property-related taxes now account for at least 17% of total revenues, up from 4% ten years ago. As the property market slows, the scope for further upside revenue surprises is limited. |
In the Celtic Tiger period, only a small number of Irish companies have succeeded in scaling the international platform of significant companies. CRH has become the biggest building materials supplier in the US; Ryanair has become Europe's largest low-fares airline and Denis O'Brien's Digicel, which operates in 22 markets, has grown to 3,000 employees since 2001. There are a handful of other companies that have had success in niche markets and at a regional level. C&C has had significant success with Magners Cider in the UK market.
At an international level, Irish tech firms are small. One of the biggest IONA posted 2006 revenue of $77.8 million.
No Irish company has floated on the US Nasdaq Stock Exchange since 1999 – an exchange that lists more than 70 Israeli companies.
In total 86,000 jobs were created in 2006, according to the CSO. The strong growth in the Construction (+28,400) and the Health (+18,700) sectors accounted for just over 55% of the annual increase in the numbers employed. Only 6,000 jobs were created in the tradable goods/services sector of the economy, according to policy advisory agency Forfás. It had reported in January 2007 that 83,000 jobs were created in 2006.
So 7% of the jobs were in businesses producing exportable goods and services. 2,913 permanent full-time jobs were created in foreign-owned companies, and 3,014 in Irish-owned companies, supported by the State enterprise development agencies, during the fourth year of a global economic boom.
Only six jobs were created in the €110m Information Age Park Ennis (IAPE) in the past 12 months, figures released on Tuesday, June 5, 2007 by Shannon Development show.
That is 6 jobs from a total of 86,000 created nationwide in 2006.
The park was opened two years ago by Enterprise Minister Mícheál Martin, who said it had the potential to create 3,500 jobs over the next 15 years.
However, at the current rate, the IAPE will create just 330 at the end of the 15-year period.
A Shannon Development spokesman said that the numbers working at the Information Age Park are 43, increasing six from the 37 people employed at the park in May 2006.
The number of companies increased from 14 to 19.
IDA Ireland has so far failed to attract any foreign direct investment into the park, with only one visit by a potential investor to Ennis, County Clare in 2006.
China surpassed the US as the world's second-largest exporter in the middle of 2006, according to data published in April by the World Trade Organization, and the emerging economic giant is pulling further and further ahead. Ireland slipped from 26th ranking of the world's leading merchandise exporters in 2005 to 29th place in 2006.
The rankings are in US dollars and most of Ireland's exports are priced in US dollars.
The annual rise in US dollar terms in 2006 for Ireland of 3%, was the lowest increase of the world's top 30 exporters and compared with a rise of 15% for the global number 1 - Germany.
Global export volume grew by 8% in 2006, the second highest rate since 2000, according to preliminary figures from the World Trade Organisation.
The world is in the fifth year of the longest sustained period of economic growth since the late 1960’s but Ireland is faltering.
The simple truth is that the opportunities in China and India depend on the continued dominance of US multinational firms in the Irish economy but the magnet of low costs and growing markets is already gaining force and the direction of investment is being pulled towards the East.
In May, Bank of Ireland Chief Economist Dr. Dan McLaughlin, said in an address to the Irish House Builders Association that it is not clear from some of the more bearish forecasts on the Irish economy whether the authors envisage a cyclical slowdown or a structural shift in Irish growth. The former would be relatively short lived as in time lower interest rates would eventually prompt a cyclical recovery, as in the 2001 – 2003 period.
A move to a lower potential growth rate would be more serious but it is not obvious why the potential growth of the Irish economy should fall from 5.5% - 6% to 3.5% - 4% in eighteen months as it would require a sharp fall in productivity or a substantial fall in labour force growth. Some even argue that the Irish potential growth rate is not currently in this 5.5% - 6% range, but if lower, unemployment would have surely fallen, when in fact it has been very stable over the last few years.
|Source: Goodbody Stockbrokers|
The Government plans to spend €3.8 billion on R&D to create a “world-class knowledge economy” by 2013 – note that I did not write that it has a “plan.”
The overall goal is a pipedream although deepening the Irish research base will pay some dividends long-term.
In the long-run we’re all dead as the renowned British economist John Maynard Keynes onetime remarked but looking beyond the time horizon of bank economists, just consider an interesting factoid - in the first quarter, €4.2 million in venture capital was invested in young innovative firms in Ireland, significantly down from €26.3 million in 4Q’06 and the €28.6 million invested in 1Q’06. Only one deal was completed in 1Q’07, down from 4 deals in 4Q’06 and 7 in 1Q’06 – and wonder if such a development in the context of:
- poor productivity in the agricultural sector
- unchanged productivity in the food sector between 1995-2005 (See : Perspectives on Irish Productivity - March 2007)
- poor export growth during a global economic boom
- Construction and Civil Engineering companies continuing to dominate Irish start-ups
- Irish-owned exportable goods/services sector looking unlikely to fill void left by contracting foreign-owned sector
- the high watermark of the construction sector with 281,000 employed compared with 126,100 in early 1998
- a society where entrepreneurship is a greater challenge than it has ever been
is nothing to get excited about.
Compared with Israeli companies, Irish tech companies have been unable to sale up fast to be significant players. Think of Ryanair in aviation and Nokia in electronics. So even with a lot of State support, the promoters can sell out before roots are put down in home territory.
Should we focus more attention on food rather than tech? We will always have the raw materials and being pioneers in Europe where people will always eat, potential opportunities will always be there.
|CNBC report from 2005 looking forward 10 years - The economy underpinned by demographics and European Central Bank rate of 2%; baby boom from 70's and 80's boosting housing demand; Role of multinational sector overstated - only accounts for 6% to 7% of economy.|
Even if the ECB rate goes to 5% in 2008 - up 150% from December 2005, the argument is that interest rates will start falling again from 2009. So we can still depend on construction, including the infrastructure development programme.
NCB Stockbrokers' economist Eunan King sanguinely said on the RTÉ Prime Time television programme (you need to have the Real Player installed - free download) on Thursday, June 7th, that competitiveness of the Irish economy hasn't been eroded; the economy is not overdependent on the property sector; he said that we've a young population and the demand for houses will continue as it has been for most of the next ten years.
Few look beyond ten years - - even though economic trends generally have long gestation periods.
In 2005, the State funded Rural Development Report 2025, said: Growth in exports from the dominant indigenous enterprises will remain relatively low. Moreover, it is likely that a large part of manufacturing output from foreign owned enterprises will move to lower cost economies. In these circumstances, employment in building and construction will not continue at current high levels.
It's easy now to downplay the role of the multinational sector that is responsible for over 90% of our exports, but from say 2017, will we still be on the pig's back through selling houses to each other?
Property Investment long a No-Brainer
Venture capital investment in Irish companies in 2006 amounted to just €192 million invested in 52 enterprises compared with Irish investors putting €11 billion in commercial property - €3 billion of this was spent on domestic deals.
While some lollipops have been offered to promote business start-ups in the export sector over the past decade, a halving of capital gains tax from 40% to 20% coupled with a massive extension of tax incentive schemes for domestic construction at a time when economic fundamentals were very strong, made property the default investment and the riskier export sector was just frozen out.
Accountancy firms soon found that producing business plans for start-ups was a mugs’ game compared with getting involved in property investment.
On Monday, June 4th 2007, a unit of a firm of chartered accountants from the West Cork town of Clonakilty, announced plans to invest a further €100 million in German commercial property. CMC Capital, the Cork-based wealth management and property investment division of Crowley & McCarthy Chartered Accountants plan to raise €20 million in equity for their new German commercial property syndicate from Irish investors.
CMC Capital has successfully invested €500 million in German commercial property on behalf of syndicate and private client investors since first entering the market in 2004. This includes the recent purchase, through a joint venture with a UK partner, of Germany’s busiest shopping centre, the A10 Centre outside Berlin, for €245 million.
The minimum investment in the new syndicate will be €100,000 with €10,000 increments thereafter. The €20m in equity will be combined with non-recourse finance of 80% , creating an expected total portfolio value of €100 million.
So West Cork farmers although inefficient compared with their German counterparts, may well be investing the proceeds of Common Agricultural Policy welfare, funded by German taxpayers, on German property.
Post-Property Boom Ireland
During the Celtic Tiger period, the chasm between the public and private sectors was illustrated by the success of public service trade unions in winning demands while much of the private sector received scant coverage in the traditional national media.
The public sector, which has grown by 77,000 since 1997, has held the public megaphone and received special sham benchmarking awards without having to accept any significant reform.
The Paris-based government think-tank, the OECD, is due to put forward proposals on Irish public service reform by December 2007 but it’s a fair bet that apart from some cosmetic changes, nothing of significance will be adopted.
Some segments of the private sector have done well from the Celtic Tiger.
Hired hands of established companies in segments with little exposure to international competition, have coasted while convincing themselves that success is due to managerial brilliance.
Developers have reaped a bonanza and have left a footprint in the commercial property markets in Europe and the US. Some €41 billion has been invested in commercial property since 2001 – most of it in London.
In the services sector, almost all enterprises (98%) are small. There were 83,500 small businesses which employed over 400,000 people in services in 2004. This was more than half of total employment in the sector.
It’s not clear how many have also rode the property tiger but we will know in time.
While 100,000 jobs will be shed in the construction sector (housing accounts for 66% of the output) in the next decade, it may be some consolation that the average annual industrial earnings of €40,000 in the sector, is far above the average industrial wage of €32,0000.
Irish factory gate prices decreased by 0.3% in April 2007. This compares to a decrease of 0.2% recorded for April of last year. As a result, the annual percentage change showed a decrease of 1.5% in April 2007, which compares to a decrease of 1.4% in March 2007.
Trying to achieve productivity gains with inflation running above the EU average and unable to raise prices, life has been far from rosy.
In our apparently prosperous economy, some 900,000 workers from a total of 2,100,000 have no occupational pensions.
It is estimated that the annual pension cost for the recipients of the sham benchmarking payments, is 28% of salary for each year of a 40-year career.
A fund of almost €20 billion has already been built up for public service pensions while the majority of private sector workers who retire, rely on the being part of a political auction at election time.
As tax revenues from property were in the range 25%-30% of total revenue in 2006 (17% directly from property taxes), a sustained contraction in the property market, will involve a painful adjustment for politicians and public.
The free lunch was never invented.
Adjusting the Mindset?
When the decline of the construction sector will hit the economy, investment in overseas commercial property will become even a bigger play for people with money. In recent days, Goodbody Stockbrokers have invested €210 million in two buildings in London and Paris on behalf of clients.
In our globalised world, there will likely be opportunities for killings somewhere.
Investment in the Irish exportable goods/services sector will remain the poor relation.
The increase in the Business Expansion Scheme in the December 2006 Budget will have a marginal impact on investment in Irish enterprise.
So the aspiration of creating a world class knowledge economy is to provide more research personnel for the foreign-owned enterprises. Some jobs termed as “high quality” or “high calibre” by Enterprise Minister Micheál Martin will be created but process jobs will be lost and it’s hard to see where sufficient jobs will be created to enable us to remain a Top 30 global exporter.
An international advisor to Irish government and State agencies warned on Wednesday, June 06, 2007 that Irish businesses lack the confidence to become world business leaders.
Innovation specialist Professor Danny Breznitz of the Georgia Institute of Technology says our research infrastructure is too narrow in its focus and may not be sustainable.
He says we are not creating enough new businesses, and when new businesses are set up, the financial supports are not there to keep them innovating.
Breznitz says the building of Ireland's R&D infrastructure is something that should be imitated by other countries, but he said he feared that Irish research is too narrowly focussed on biotech and the ICT, or information and communications technology industries.
Professor Breznitz said that if a country wants sustained economic growth it has to focus on innovation, not only on the research side but on the commercialisation and the growth of productivity.