| Click for the Finfacts Ireland Portal Homepage |

Finfacts Business News Centre

News Main Page 
 
 News
 Irish
 European
 International
 Asia-Pacific Business Week
 
 Analysis/Comment

RSS FEED


How to use our RSS feed

 
Web Finfacts

Welcome

Finfacts is Ireland's leading business information site and you are in its business news section.

We provide access to live business television and business related videos from: Bloomberg TV; The Wall Street Journal; CNBC and the Financial Times. Click image:

Links

Finfacts Homepage

Global News

Bloomberg News

CNN Money

Cnet Tech News

Newspapers

Irish Independent

Irish Times

Irish Examiner

New York Times

Financial Times

Technology News

 

Feedback

 

Search

News : European Last Updated: Dec 19th, 2007 - 13:17:15


France is the 2006 winner of the Euro Health Consumer Index; Ireland and Lithuania provide the worst health care in Europe
By Finfacts Team
Jun 26, 2006, 20:35

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

The Euro Health Consumer Index 2006 identifies the most consumer-friendly health care system in the European union, as rated by 27 Index indicators. The 2006 Index includes all the 25 EU public healthcare systems plus Switzerland for reference.

France emerges as the 2006 winner of the Euro Health Consumer Index, "with a technically efficient and generously providing healthcare system". France scores 576 out of 750 maximum points. 2005 years winner, the Netherlands, now takes the silver position, followed by Germany. Estonia and Slovakia gets the highest ranking in the category "value for money".

In five categories, covering 28 performance indicators, Ireland scores 359 points out of a potential 750.

The survey points out that Irish waiting times are long, medical outcomes are bleak, that there is a high level of infant deaths, and a high number MRSA infections in Irish hospitals.

Ireland also fares badly in terms of patients' rights. The survey also pointed out that Ireland lacks a Patients' Ombudsman, the right to a second opinion, or an all-day telephone or web-based healthcare information service.

Taking a strong consumer view, the 2006 Euro Health Consumer Index seeks to add to already existing evaluations by institutions like WHO and OECD. Introducing a different perspective, its Index ranks how user-friendly the national healthcare turns out around the Union.

Analysing the position of the consumer as shown by the 2006 Index, Euro Health finds for example that:

- Only four EU countries out of 25 offer some kind of provider catalogue (just one with a quality ranking).

- Three out of four national systems cannot treat your cancer within three weeks.

- In only one out of three you have direct access to a medical specialist.

- The same goes for the right to a second opinion.

- Every second country blocks the patient´s access to her own medical record.

- Two out of three governments delays the introduction of new pharmaceuticals into the reimbursement system.

To see the full results: EHCI 2006 grid
To read the report: 
EHCI 2006 Report 

Results in the BFB (Bang for Buck) Score sheet

The outcome of the BFB exercise is shown in the table below. Even with the square root exercise described in a previous section of the report, the effect is definitely to dramatically elevate all the less affluent nations in the scoring sheet.

Content summary

France emerges as the 2006 winner of the Euro Health Consumer Index (EHCI), with a technically efficient and generously providing healthcare system. France scores 576 out of 750 maximum points. It is sometimes argued that “the French healthcare system has severe budget deficit problems”. The author would like to note that budget deficits in public sector areas, which are not financed for performance and work in a situation of competition, are more or less arbitrary! As long as “France, S.A.” is reasonably solvent, black or red figures in its healthcare system are not very significant.

The scoring has intentionally been done in such a way that the likelihood that two states should end up sharing a position in the ranking is almost zero. It must therefore be noted that France, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, Germany and Luxembourg are really very difficult to separate, and that very subtle changes in single scores modify the internal order of these six top countries.

One interesting thing about the top six states is that they achieve their top positions in very different ways. Sweden reaches 4th place almost entirely because of a solid victory in the Outcomes quality discipline, and with very poor performance on Accessibility.

(Radically improving Medical Outcomes is a much more laborious and much longer process than reducing waiting times.) This means that if healthcare officials and politicians took to looking across borders, and “steal” good things from their EU neighbours, there is a good chance for a nation to come much closer to the theoretical top score of 750.

In southern Europe, Spain and Italy provide excellent healthcare services. Real excellence in southern European healthcare seems to be a bit too much dependent on the consumers’ ability to afford private healthcare as a supplement to public healthcare for these countries to reach top scores.

A mixed performance is shown by the UK, which wins out on healthcare information.

The overall U.K. score is dragged down by waiting lists and uneven quality performance.

The CEE member states are doing surprisingly well, considering their much smaller healthcare spend in Purchasing Power adjusted dollars per capita. However, readjusting from planned to consumer-driven economies does take time. Slovenia and Estonia, being the smallest ships to turn around, seem to lead this subgroup, and are clear winners in the academic exercise in our value-for-money adjusted Index – the “Bang-for-the-Buck” score.

Related:

Rising health costs put pressure on public finances, finds OECD; Ireland's spending on health among lowest of any Developed Country

Think-tank Health Consumer Powerhouse is the leading European provider of consumer information on health care. The Powerhouse is dedicating ideas and resources to the development of consumer empowerment action. It analyses health care and compare the outcomes, designing consumer information tools like health care system and Illnesses indexes, consumer press and education. It is registered Swedish entity working from Stockholm and Brussels and soon also in Canada.

RELATED

Euro Health Consumer Index 2006: Letter to Editor response to Mary Harney on Irish health care classification among worst in Europe


© Copyright 2007 by Finfacts.com

Top of Page

European
Latest Headlines
German ZEW Indicator of Economic Sentiment fell in January to a to 15-Year low indicating plunge in investor confidence
UK Annual Consumer Price Inflation held steady in December at 2.1%
Total cost of employment in Ireland at €38,541in 2007 - 16th of 24 EU countries; New EU member states have lowest labour costs
European Union countries fighting over share-out for cutting greenhouse gas emissions; Environment Commissioner now says some biofuels do more harm than good
UK factory gate/wholesale price annual inflation rose to 5% in December - the highest since 1991
Eurozone industrial production fell 0.5% in November
Manchester United almost doubled profit in 2007; Premier League clubs’ revenues to increase significantly in 2007/08 to over £1.76bn
Trichet says ECB is in position of "total alertness" to act in response to price/wage setting linked to the current high Eurozone headline inflation rate
European Central Bank keeps its its benchmark interest rate on hold at 4.00%; Trichet to warn of inflation risks at press conference
Bank of England keeps benchmark interest rate unchanged at 5.50%
European Central Bank expected to keep benchmark interest rate on hold at 4%; Bank of England base rate cut likely
Eurozone Economic Outlook: GDP growth to slow to annual rate of 2.1% in Q2 2008; If negative shocks were to fade economic slowdown may be only transitory
European Commission analysis looks at the role of India in world agriculture
Eurozone GDP revised up to 0.8% in Q3 2007 - up 2.7% in year to September
German exports and retail sales fell in November 2007
UK Consumer Confidence fell in December; Marks & Spencer reports first same-store sales fall in 2 1/2 years on reduced Christmas spending
Eurozone retail sales volume fell 0.5% in November 2007 - down 1.4% on annual basis but up 0.9% in EU27
UK Retail Sales December 2007: A far from Merry Christmas in the High Street
UK sales of commercial property plunged in Q4 2007 because of credit crunch; Market set for biggest annual losses in more than 25 years
Eurozone Business Climate Indicator and Economic Sentiment Indicator weakened in December 2007