We provide access to
live business television and business related videos from:
Bloomberg TV; The Wall Street Journal; CNBC and the
Financial Times. Click image:
"Time
in the Market" Versus "Timing the Market," 1963-1993
Source:
Ibbotson Associates
Source:
University of Michigan
In the 1990's the
New York Stock Exchange-where the stocks of about 3,000 companies are
traded among investors each day- had its longest "bull market" (a
period of rising stock prices) in its history. The NASDAQ-where the
stocks of approximately 3,300 companies are traded- also experienced
record performance. Following a
sustained period of rapid stocks/shares value growth, it takes
time during the downturn for memories of disappearing paper profits and high profile corporate failures, to
fade. So the scenario for the foreseeable future is unspectacular average equity returns growth compared with
successive years in the 1990s of double-digit
growth. However, some sectors and regions will continue
to outperform others. In a long period down/bear market,
there are always periods of growth. So the timing of
stock market investment is important. The last protracted
bear market (period of falling prices) in US equities started in February 1966 and
lasted until August 1982. The Dow Jones index value in
February 1966 was 995 and 16 years later it stood at 777.
So any investor who stayed fully invested in an average
portfolio of shares in this period lost 22%. Yet over
this time span there were four periods in which equities
experienced strong rallies which boosted the Dow by 32%,
66%, 76% and 38% respectively.
According to a
University of Michigan study, an investor who stayed in the US stock market
during the entire 30-year period from 1963 to 1993-7,802 trading days-would
have had an average annual return of 11.83 %. However, if the investor missed
the 90 best days while trying to time the market, the average return
would have fallen to 3.28% per annum.
According
to Dr. Bryan Taylor of Global Financial Data, analysis of US bull
and bear markets in the past has always used the S&P Composite Price
Index, not the Total Return Index. Since
most investors have their money in funds that reinvest their dividends, using
a price index to determine the movement of markets does not reflect the
results that investors receive. Over
time, price indices produce dramatically different results from return
indices. The 1920s bull market peaked on September 7, 1929.
If someone had invested their money in the stock market on September 7,
1929, it would have taken until September 1954 to break even using the price
index benchmark but on
a total return basis (allowing for dividends), the investor would have broken
even nine
years earlier, in 1945. Total returns reduce the size of the falls in a bear
market and increase the returns in a bull market.
The Global
Investment Returns Yearbook (originally
known as The Millennium Book) was launched in 2000. It is produced by
London Business School experts Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton in
conjunction with ABN AMRO. ABN AMRO distributes the Yearbook to
investment professionals and London Business School makes it available to
other users
Figure 5: Real returns on equities and bonds internationally, 1900-2007
Large scale
chart of Figure 5 plus more charts and information in a Synopsis of the
2007 Report
There are opportunities for long-term investors to
outperform when the market takes a short-term view on risk, says ABN
AMRO / London Business School study.
For long-term investors, protecting portfolios against
short-term losses is counterproductive and downside protection hurts
performance disproportionately, according to the authors of the
ABN AMRO Global Investment Returns Yearbook
2007.
ABN
AMRO is a leading Dutch bank.
Returns 1900-2006
Figure 5 shows that out of the 17 GIRY countries, the
best performing equity markets over the very long term are Sweden and
Australia, with annualised percentage real returns since 1900 of 7.9%
and 7.8%, respectively, compared to a world average of 5.8%. Ireland had
a real annual return of 5%
The core of the Yearbook
is provided by a long-run study covering 107 years of investment since
1900 in all the main asset categories in Australia, Belgium, Canada, Denmark,
France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Norway, South Africa,
Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States. These
markets today make up over 92% of world equity market capitalisation. With the
unrivalled quality and breadth of its database, the Yearbook has
established itself as the global authority on long-run stock, bond, bill and
foreign exchange performance.
The
Dow Jones Industrials Average is based on 30 stocks of leading companies and represents about 25% of the New York Stock Exchange market capitalisation. The S&P Composite represents about 75% of the market’s
capitalisation.